Lincoln Center Whirl and Twirl

It is about the dance. It is about the crowd. It is about the dance.

The dance, choreographed by Mark Dendy, is called “Ritual Cyclical,” and it takes place at Lincoln Center, at the north end of its outdoor plaza, on the Upper West Side of Manhattan.

Not at the fountain. That would be too conventional.


It takes place at the pool, the rectangular, shallow reflecting pool crowned with a sculpture by Henry Moore.

We know the dance is supposed to mysteriously start out of nowhere so as soon as Josefa and I get there we start looking for signs.

It’s hard, because New York is all signs. We have heard there will be some eighty dancers in this flash-mob-ish piece, so anyone could be a performer. Everyone is facing the pool, then someone dressed in business clothes will bolt behind you, a hand on your shoulder. A dancer.

A disembodied voice welcomes us: How to see this piece? Fluidly, moving along, circulating, there is no front, it’s all around, constantly shifting, and changing, and the audience needs to change with it.

We talk about cameras. Josefa has a great camera and a better eye, and most of these are her images.

josefa camera

How to get the best shot here, where good shots are difficult? I complain that I can’t get a long-distance picture and Josefa tells me a little about the debate over the telephoto lens. In the world of photography, she says, there is thinking going on about what is the responsible way to document something. Is it intimate in a way that is not so good to shoot from far away, rather than close to the subject? The telephoto might be dishonest.

Around peoples’ heads, around  peoples’ cameras, we see people holding their hands up to the sky, waggling their fingers.


It’s as if they are hailing a space ship. The music of the Kronos Quartet soars from speakers all around. It’s six o’clock, just past the afternoon and still not dusk. An hour of expectation, and this piece seems to be a lot about expectation. We’re all crushed up against one another, against hair and shoulders, bellies, hips. It isn’t so bad, strangely.

summer new yorker

New Yorkers in their summer finery.

red glasses

The woman with red glasses has a green tatto of a number on the back of her neck. Josefa always wonders what the numbers mean.

Kids in fatigues already barked at spectators to stand back, clear the area. But the crowds surge.


There’s a bum sitting on a concrete bench. Should he be here? Really. Harrumph.

bum sitting

Now girls in white are caressing the water, dripping it across their bodies. A beautiful white-shirted man removes a golden crown from his head.

white girls in water

The dance has begun.

It proceeds on all surfaces, all around, people writhing and twirling, in all manner of costume.

pool dancer

A young man and woman splash and play and court in the middle of the water. She goes piggyback. Up on the green grass plane above the pool, an audience of three dancers stretch their bodies, do what dancers do.

white boy and girl

Then the crowd shifts to the grove of small trees just to the south. Human forms in blue, grey trunks. Josefa: It must be nice to dance against trees like that.

blue dancers

They collapse, and other dancers erupt, doing Latin steps next door.

We have a realization. The bum is a dancer. He has appeared everywhere, and is not an interoper, except in our consciousness.

bum blur

His clothes are dirty, he picks up trash from the ground. A dirty dancer. Josefa takes pictures as he twirls, relishing his intransigence.


Is he homeless? a man asks me.

No, he’s a dancer.

The homeless dance? he says.

For a finale there is a stage in front of the New York Public Library for the Performing Arts and American tunes: The Battle Cry of Freedom, Dixieland, Elvis, Hendrix.

USA! USA! The performers yell. The crowd presses up close yet everyone gives each other room, room to breathe.


We can smell sweat – the dancers’? Our own?


They hoist a flag a la Iwo Jima. American uniforms, then, wow, the vogue-ing, marching dancers strip to their briefs and pitch their shirts and pants out to the audience like rock stars.


We don’t care, we’re New Yorkers, but still it’s pretty cool.

Mark Dendy told The New Yorker, “Every day, every New Yorker comes into contact with about two hundred thousand other people, and they all depend on each other. So in this piece we do this thing called New York City together.”

Do they ever.


Filed under Dance, Fashion, Jean Zimmerman, Music, Photography

9 responses to “Lincoln Center Whirl and Twirl

  1. Pingback: Thank You for Reading | Jean Zimmerman

  2. So glad you got to see my post. I guess the bum was really a dancer after all! He was boss.

  3. hi Jean
    thank you so much for these kind words. it is just so gratifying when someone “gets it” as you well know and it is added sweetness when they share “getting it” with others! cheers!!!!

  4. Lydia

    I’m sorry I missed this! I recognized one dancer in the plaid. New York is so big, yet so small.

  5. Exactly what it felt like, a merging.

  6. Anonymous

    Amazing! I do so wish I could have been there instead of here doing my homework. *sigh* What a wonderful thing to have been part of, for in observing you became part of the event. Without you and those like you, there would not have been such an event. It would have simply been a dance. With you, however, it became … a Happening!

  7. Well, from what I observed and surmised, all was planned, even the “homeless” dancer.


    What a strange happening… a huge cast of dancers, but at least partly improvisational? Interesting photos and observations… I wonder about the green tattoo, too.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s